Joe Whitetree

Dr. Dwight Mahoney

Father Davis

Dracula

Detective Howard, Eddie

Andrea Barr

Mark Telesca, Spencer Wallis

Peter Holloway, Tamiel

Sheriff

Samuel Campbell, Azazel, Shapeshifter

Dr. Aaron Fuller

Lila Taylor, Violet Duval

Phantasm

Larry Pike

Hilary

Demon #1, Minion #1, Minion #2

Rita Johnson

Hansel, Tooth Fairy

Leticia Gore Actress

Claire Becker

Detective Madsen

Alice

Joba, Officer Walter Kelly

Demon Henchman #1

Amara, Amara (Child)

Gadreel, Ezekiel

Adina

Young Dean Winchester

Pierce Moncrieff

Gilda

Duane Tanner